Rethinking Fonterra regulation: value creation, not factory counting

Rethinking Fonterra regulation: value creation, not factory counting

Summary

Dr Nic Lees, a senior lecturer in agribusiness management at Lincoln University, argues in an opinion piece that the Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) review of the Dairy Industry Restructuring Act (DIRA) should focus on which institutional arrangement delivers the greatest long-term economic benefit for New Zealand, rather than simply whether Fonterra needs regulation. DIRA was introduced in 2001 when Fonterra was formed, allowing the creation of a large dairy co-operative while putting in place regulation to prevent it from restricting competition. At its formation, Fonterra collected about 96 percent of New Zealand's milk; that has now fallen to about 78 percent, with the remainder purchased by competing processors.

The review will decide whether current regulation is retained, modified or removed. Lees notes that New Zealand's dairy exports earn nearly NZ$29 billion a year, processing requires substantial investment in plants, transport networks and marketing infrastructure, large plants have lower unit production costs, and Fonterra's nationwide milk collection network delivers efficiencies that small processors struggle to match. Competition has increased significantly since Fonterra's formation, with companies such as Open Country Dairy and Synlait investing in processing facilities, developing alternative business models and speciality dairy products, but competition also has costs: duplicating processing plants and milk collection networks adds cost, especially when plant capacity is underutilised.

New Zealand First has proposed a 'Use It or Lose It' dairy policy that would give eligible manufacturers investing in high-value dairy production up to 500 million litres of milk a year for up to ten years, compared with the current 50 million litre cap for some eligible processors, aimed at encouraging investment in domestic dairy manufacturing, job creation and high-value exports. The article also mentions Fonterra's sale of its consumer business to French dairy company Lactalis, raising questions about future dairy processing investment and where profits will accrue. Lees stresses that additional processing capacity does not necessarily create additional economic value; if new plants merely duplicate existing capacity or divert milk, the economic gains may be limited and could encourage investment that would not be commercially viable without government regulation, so the proposed pricing arrangements are important to ensure the full economic cost of milk supply is recognised.

He also points to the question of where value accrues: Fonterra is owned by New Zealand dairy farmers, so profits and milk payments largely flow back into the domestic economy; foreign-owned processors also contribute through jobs, investment, tax and purchasing milk from New Zealand farmers, but some profits ultimately flow to overseas shareholders, so higher dairy export revenue does not necessarily mean an equivalent increase in income retained in New Zealand. The article argues that the biggest opportunity may lie in creating more value from existing milk production, and with limited room for dairy expansion, future growth will increasingly depend on speciality ingredients, nutritional products, new technology and high-value markets.

Commentary

The core of New Zealand's dairy regulation review is not whether Fonterra needs regulation, but which institutional arrangement will maximise New Zealand's long-term economic interests. Fonterra's milk collection share has fallen from 96 percent at its formation to 78 percent; increased competition has brought efficiency gains but also duplicated processing capacity. New Zealand First's proposed 'Use It or Lose It' policy would raise the milk allocation for eligible processors from 50 million litres to 500 million litres, aimed at encouraging high-value investment, but there is a need to guard against limited economic gains if new plants merely divert existing milk.

After Fonterra's sale of its consumer business to France's Lactalis, future processing investment and profit attribution have become a focus. While foreign-owned processors contribute jobs and tax, some profits flow overseas, so higher export revenue does not equal an equivalent increase in income retained in New Zealand. For New Zealand small and medium business owners, future dairy growth will depend on speciality ingredients, nutritional products and high-value markets, offering opportunities for SMEs with R&D capabilities to enter niche segments, but they need to assess the impact of regulatory changes on raw milk supply and pricing.

Keywords: Fonterra, Dairy Industry Restructuring Act, Ministry for Primary Industries, milk collection, New Zealand First, high-value dairy products, Lactalis, farmer ownership


AI illustration on MiDeer Observer

Source: Waikatotimes

Disclaimer: This article is compiled from publicly available sources for general information only. The analysis and commentary are editorial opinions. MiDeer Observer does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information provided. Readers should seek independent professional advice before relying on this content, or contact us for more information.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *